Herald Malasiya Online

You are Here:  Home   News

What next in Allah row?

Published On January 05 , 2010
Comments(2)  |   Mail  |   Print  |  
KUALA LUMPUR: The government today filed for a stay of execution pending its appeal of a court ruling allowing Catholic weekly Herald to describe the Christian God as “Allah”, amid growing Islamic anger in the country.

Following are some questions and answers on what lies ahead and the political implications of a row threatening to increase religious tensions in the mainly Muslim but multi-racial country.

Why is the issue arousing so much anger?

The issue stems from The Herald’s successful legal bid to overturn a government ban against the paper’s use of the word “Allah” to describe the Christian God in its Malay language edition.

It is illegal for non-Muslims to proselytise to Muslims, although freedom of worship for the mainly Buddhist, Christian and Hindu religious minorities who make up 40 per cent of the country’s 28 million population is guaranteed under the constitution.

The use of the word “Allah” has been common among non-English speaking Christians in Sabah and Sarawak for decades and without any incident.

What happens next?


The case is now before the Appeals Court. That court’s verdict can still be challenged at the Federal Court, the country’s top court, whose decision will be final.

The appeals process is often lengthy, taking years. But special public interest cases have been known to be expedited to within several months, which is likely in this instance.

What will be the political fallout for the government?

An attempt could be made by Barisan Nasional government that has ruled Malaysia for 52 years since independence to broker a conditional deal over the use of the word.

The coalition suffered its worst-ever setbacks in national and state elections in 2008 after being abandoned by non-Malays in part due to unease over an increasing Islamisation.

Religious tensions will jeopardise Prime Minister Datuk Seri Najib Razak’s ability to win back ethnic Chinese and Indian voters in the next general election, which must be held by 2013.

A failure to regain non-Malay voter support could still allow the ruling coalition to remain in power in the next general election but only just. In such a scenario Najib’s future as premier would be in doubt.

Najib, who took office in April last year, also faces risks in his own political party as senior figures in his United Malays National Organisation (Umno), the lynchpin of the coalition, have opposed the use of the word Allah by non-Muslims.

And on the opposition?

The row also has implications for the three-party Pakatan Rakyat opposition led by former deputy premier Datuk Seri Anwar Ibrahim, especially the Islamist Pan Malaysian Islamic Party (PAS).

PAS and its partner, the secular, Chinese-backed Democratic Action Party (DAP) have frequently clashed over issues such as pork, alcohol and PAS insistence on setting up an Islamic state.

PAS has adopted a cautious stand on the Allah issue, reflecting a split within the party leadership, agreeing that Christians have a right to use the word but urging the word not be used in a manner that could jeopardise religious harmony.

Anwar’s ability to manage any row that could emerge between leaders in the opposition will be important.

Are religious tension in Malaysia an investment risk?

Not directly. Religious disputes are a risk mostly in their potential to increase ethnic tensions, with the biggest fear being a repeat of ethnic clashes that took place in May 1969.

Some investors are concerned over the increasing Islamisation of Malaysia as a potential market risk.

During a meeting with investors in New York last year Najib, was asked about the government’s stand over the caning sentence meted out to a Muslim woman for drinking beer under rarely-enforced Islamic criminal laws.

An escalation of religious tensions in Malaysia could weaken Najib’s ability to push through economic reforms aimed at boosting foreign investment.

Is there a risk of ethnic clashes?

The risk is very small. The bloody 1969 clashes left a deep scar on the national psyche.

Any signs of trouble would see the government use the Internal Security Act (ISA) that allows detention without trial.

While there are likely to be protests organised by fringe groups, there is no real risk of attacks on churches or other places of worship.

Courtesy: TheMalaysianInsider
BOOKMARK AND SHARE WITH FRIENDS:;  Digg! Reddit! Del.icio.us! Mixx! Google! Live! Facebook! Slashdot! Netscape! Technorati! StumbleUpon! Spurl! MySpace! Wists! Newsvine! Furl! Yahoo! Ma.gnolia! Squidoo! Swik!
Post A Comment On This Story And Express Your Suggestion
Name:
City/State/Country:
E-Mail:
Comment:

Most Commented News

Home Ministry files appeal over ‘Allah’ ruling
Top Stories and Catholic Christian News-2010-01-04 06:18:13
Stepping forward to be of service to the public
Top Stories-2010-03-07 23:10:00
Four reasons for controversial ‘Allah’ ruling
Top Stories-2010-01-17 03:40:00
Daughters of St. Paul unfazed by threats from Church of Scientology
Global Chrstian News-2010-01-13 04:28:02

Most Emailed News

    Focus
    On Dec 31, 2009, the Malaysian High Court ruled that Christians in Malaysia have the constitutional right to use the word “Allah” to refer to God and that the word is not exclusive to Islam.
    Photo Highlight

    A rosary made with small fragments of the Berlin Wall is displayed at the Catholic shrine of Fatima in Portugal.
    Herald Childrens Section
    Herald Youth Special
    Herald Archives
    On litmus tests for Christian discipleshipWe live today with a lot of polarization, both inside of our churches and in society at large. There....
    A particularly joyous weddingTwo weeks ago I presided at a wedding ceremony. All weddings are special, but this one was particula....
    A different way of doing businessIn fact, conventional economic theory dictates that the primary and over-riding motive of a corporat....

    Top Comments On Stories

    629 eager to be baptisedFrom: Malaysia News - Commented By : Fair Comment : - What is the numbers of elect from the 3 new parishes making their fi....
    Tiga diakon untuk Keuskupan Agung Kota KinabaluFrom: Malaysian Language News - Commented By : Hailey : - semoga Tuhan Yesus Kristus sentiasa beserta mereka selalu...
    Yusuf dan kisah NatalFrom: Malaysian Language News - Commented By : ahli syurga crew : - 
    Cardinal Vlk warns of ‘Islamization’ of Europe, calls for return to ChristianityFrom: Global Chrstian News - Commented By : TheCatholic Observer : - The ultimate question to be asked is how come Christianity has faded....
    Herald Spiritual Resources