Synod on Synodality ‘is not sociological analysis of the Church’

A Vatican cardinal has said that the Synod on Synodality is a process of discernment, not a sociological survey.

Mar 11, 2022

German bishops and other Catholic leaders gather for the first working session of the synodal way in Frankfurt. (NCR photo/Philipp Gessler)

By Hannah Brockhaus

A Vatican cardinal has said that the Synod on Synodality is a process of discernment, not a sociological survey. “This synodal process is not a sociological analysis of the Church, it is a discernment process. And when we say discernment, it means that we are trying to listen to the Holy Spirit,” said Cardinal Mario Grech.

In October 2021, the Catholic Church began the first phase of a global two-year synodal process, culminating in a meeting of the Synod of Bishops in Rome in 2023.

Grech, the Secretary General of the Synod of Bishops, is the meeting’s chief organiser.

The Maltese cardinal said that the question that the Synod on Synodality was trying to answer is, “what type of Church is the Holy Spirit enlightening us to have for today?” “By presenting this, these themes, to the people of God, we hope that we can help them to engage in this discernment process in a prayerful attitude,” he said in a recent interview.

“Because after all, this is not an exchange of opinions — I say mine and you say yours — but together, as a community, we try to do this personal discernment and this ecclesial discernment, that is listening to the Holy Spirit together.”

The Synod on Synodality is currently in the diocesan phase, when each bishop is asked to undertake a consultation process with his local Church and send the conclusions to the Vatican by Aug 15.

A second, continental phase will take place from September 2022 to March 2023, ahead of the XVI Ordinary General Assembly of the Synod of Bishops at the Vatican in October 2023.

Grech said that one of the greatest challenges was understanding “what synodality really implies.”

“Though it is a constitutional element of the Church, unfortunately, we still have difficulty to figure out now what synodality means, how we can really walk together, how we can really create space for all the baptised so that we can be one Church. I think, yes, this is one of the difficulties that we are encountering,” the 65-year-old cardinal said.

Grech added that the meaning of synodality was becoming clearer as time went on and that people were becoming more engaged and interested in the synodal process.

“Obviously, as I have already hinted, this is a spiritual exercise, a spiritual experience. So, I think one of the important dimensions of this process is that we kneel down and we open our ears to the Word of God,” he said.

“Otherwise, I’m afraid that we will transform this profoundly ecclesial experience into a worldly experience, and this is not good.”

The theme of the 2023 Rome assembly is For a Synodal Church: Communion, Participation, and Mission.

Grech explained that there are different kinds of “synods” in the Catholic Church.

“For example, Church councils are synods, and the Church councils brought about an evolution in doctrine, but if we say for example, diocesan synod, or a national synod, those are different experiences of a synodal Church,” he said.

He described the “Synodal Way” in Germany as a “synodal experience on a national level,” together with the Plenary Council in Australia and the national synods being prepared in Ireland and Italy.

“Synodality is considered an important dimension of the Church, and so every Church, even a local one, a particular Church is encouraged to assume this synodal style. Yet every synod has its own level of importance,” he said.

Grech explained that his office at the Vatican was available to help and accompany Church leaders in different countries in their “synodal experience.”

Even the present Synod of Bishops, he said, “has no power to change any doctrine. The synod obviously can go more in depth, about the truth, our tenets of faith. But then as Episcopalis communio says, it’s up to the Holy Father to make the final decision. He is Peter for the Church. And we have this trust in him. Through the synod, bishops, Peter, listening to all the people of God, obviously, we’ll get more help, more assistance to help us to find truth.”

Grech was bishop of Gozo from 2005 until his appointment to the Synod of Bishops in 2020. --CNA

Total Comments:0